It is not likely that William Shakespeare or J.D. Salinger meant for any in their literary works to function cautionary stories for younger women getting into the courting global, their so much well-known works, Hamlet and The Catcher within the Rye, respectively, have performed simply that. Hamlet, Prince of Denmark and Holden Caulfield of The Catcher within the Rye are of the worst boyfriends in all of literature. One is plagued via excessive paranoia and indecision and the opposite is an emotionally stunted guy-kid who dismisses near to everybody he meets as a “phony.”
Whilst it is exhausting to objectively pass judgement on a pair’s dating (particularly if that couple is fictional), if one spouse kills the opposite’s determine and the opposite spouse makes a decision to drown herself consequently (as is the case with Hamlet and Ophelia), it is more than likely protected to mention that the connection is dysfunctional. Holden Caulfield is not able to care for a practical dating with with reference to someone, allow on my own a lady, as a result of his emotional construction turns out to have ceased the similar day that his loved brother Allie died.
It is not that both of those males don’t seem to be in pitiable positions. Hamlet is visited by way of his father’s ghost, who tells him that his uncle (who’s now married to Hamlet’s mom; any other factor completely) is answerable for his dying and insists that Hamlet are seeking revenge. Holden is rarely in a position to transport earlier the tragic lack of his more youthful brother Allie, who died of leukemia while he used to be 11 and Holden used to be 13. Those are the types of problems which are folks within the courting global name “luggage.” And at the same time as it is not k to pass judgement on other folks for the misfortune that has befallen them, neither Hamlet nor Holden handles his cases smartly.
Hamlet makes a decision to head approximately avenging his father’s demise via: appearing loopy. No, significantly. He thinks determining to behave loopy is the most productive subsequent transfer and tells his pals to not fear in the event that they realize that he is appearing loopy, as a result of it is all a part of it his grasp plan. Ophelia, on the other hand, is aware of none of this, and simply thinks that the thing of her affection has long past spontaneously mad, and now not even in a humorous method. Hamlet is merciless to Ophelia, famously not easy that she “get thee to a nunnery!”, implying insulting issues approximately Ophelia’s honor, and breaking her center. Although nobody within the play is aware of for sure the cases surrounding Ophelia’s drowning, it is strongly implied that Hamlet’s atypical conduct and unkind movements are in charge.
In The Catcher within the Rye, Holden’s way to coping with the premature lack of his brother is just a little more uncomplicated to have in mind. The will to emotionally close down and refuse to make to any extent further shut private ties within the face of that more or less ache is extra relatable than Hamlet’s, however each males harm and alienate the individuals who care approximately them and, in consequence, revel in an much more profound loneliness themselves.
Shakespeare meant for Hamlet to be a tragedy, however it is arduous to understand if that is what Salinger had in thoughts for The Catcher within the Rye. Holden Caulfield is ceaselessly known as an anti-hero, however the argument may well be made that he is a sad hero as smartly. Even though his tale does now not result in a massacre like Hamlet’s, it is onerous to believe a cheerful long run for Holden until he is prepared to significantly amendment his conduct, which Salinger leads the reader to consider is very not likely.
Shmoop is an internet take a look at information to be informed approximately Hamlet, Catcher within the Rye and plenty of extra. Its content material is written by way of Ph.D. and Masters scholars from most sensible universities, like Stanford, Berkeley, Harvard, and Yale who’ve additionally taught at the highschool and school ranges. Academics and scholars will have to really feel assured to quote Shmoop.